ESPT
352-535-0940

Article

The Science of DUI: What Toxicology Can—and Cannot—Prove

What can DUI toxicology actually prove? Learn how Florida DUI defenses analyze blood, breath, urine, drugs, alcohol and scientific evidence.

October 15, 2026

Forensic toxicology bench with a blood vial, breath-test mouthpiece, and urine sample

The Science of DUI: What Toxicology Can—and Cannot—Prove

DUI cases often contain numbers.

A blood result.

A breath result.

A urine result.

A drug concentration.

A metabolite.

A laboratory report.

But a number is not the same thing as a conclusion.

What Toxicology Can Tell Us

Depending upon the test, toxicology may establish:

The presence of alcohol;

A measured alcohol concentration;

The presence of a drug;

The presence of a metabolite;

The concentration of a substance in a particular specimen; or

Other scientifically measurable information.

What Toxicology May Not Establish by Itself

A toxicology result does not necessarily answer every legal question.

For example:

A positive drug test does not automatically establish impairment.

A metabolite does not necessarily establish when consumption occurred.

A later alcohol concentration does not automatically establish the concentration at the moment of driving.

A breath result is not literally a blood measurement.

Florida's DUI Framework

Florida law recognizes impairment-based DUI and specified blood- and breath-alcohol concentrations of .08 or more.

Florida's testing statute separately establishes procedures for breath, blood and urine testing.

That distinction is important.

The Scientific Chain

A strong DUI defense examines the entire chain:

Driving

↓

Observation

↓

Investigation

↓

Collection

↓

Testing

↓

Laboratory analysis

↓

Scientific interpretation

↓

Legal conclusion

At every stage, the defense should ask whether the evidence supports the next step.

The Most Important Question

The question is not simply:

“Did the test detect alcohol or drugs?”

The more important question is:

“What does this scientific evidence actually prove about this defendant, at the relevant time, under Florida law?”

That is where science and criminal defense intersect.

The Law Office of Juan C. Calama has represented clients facing criminal and traffic charges for more than 20 years. A DUI case deserves more than a cursory review of a police report or laboratory number. The evidence should be examined from the roadside investigation through the scientific testing and ultimately against the elements the State must prove.

Don't just defend the charge. Defend the case. Defend the Case.

Florida DUI Defense: The Complete Step-by-Step Guide

Schedule a Free Consultation